Wednesday, April 23, 2008

To His Coy Mistress

Outline the speaker's argument in three sentences that begin with the words If, But, and Therefore. Is the argument valid?

If you love me than you would listening to me and love me back. But your not listening to me and your not giving me all that I want from you. Therefore we can't be together because I've wanted you so long that now it's just getting old.

I don't think that the argument is valid because he just wants to have some fantasy with her and it's really not true love in that case. He says your getting old and now all my lust for you is gone. He never really loved her; just wanted to have a fantasy with her.

No comments: